Our Practice Areas

Millions Of Dollars Recovered For Our Clients.
Dedicated & Tenacious Litigation Lawyers in Indianapolis

Construction Litigation Attorney in Indianapolis, IN

Construction projects involve more moving parts than almost any other kind of business relationship. Owners, general contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, architects, and sureties are all connected by a web of contracts, and a problem with one piece of that chain can quickly affect everyone else. Construction litigation covers the disputes that arise out of building projects, including payment disagreements, delays, defective work, and disputes over the terms of the construction contract itself.

Indiana has its own set of rules that shape how these disputes play out, including a mechanic’s lien statute that gives contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers a way to secure payment through the property itself, and a statute of repose that limits how long after a project’s completion a construction defect claim can be brought. Many construction contracts also include specific dispute resolution provisions, like mandatory mediation or arbitration, that affect how a disagreement has to be handled before it reaches a courtroom.

We built our construction litigation practice around a different idea than most firms in this space. Construction litigation clients usually aren’t searching for a lawyer in the middle of a crisis the way an injury victim might be. They’re general contractors, developers, property managers, and business owners who need a firm they already know and trust before a dispute escalates. At RileyCate, we work to build that relationship early, whether that means reviewing a contract before you sign it or stepping in the moment a payment dispute or defect claim starts to take shape.

We handle mechanic’s liens, construction contract disputes, construction defects, payment disputes, delay and disruption claims, and performance and payment bond claims for contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, developers, and property owners across a wide range of project types and sizes.

Because construction disputes can involve so many different parties and contracts, the first step in almost every matter is figuring out exactly where the responsibility lies. A payment problem might trace back to a dispute higher up the contract chain. A defect might involve both a design error and a workmanship issue. We spend time up front mapping out the relationships and agreements involved so the strategy we build actually fits the situation, rather than treating every construction dispute the same way, since a lien claim, a bond claim, and a straightforward breach of contract case call for very different approaches even when the underlying dollar amount is similar.

Construction disputes often involve multiple parties, overlapping contracts, and technical questions about performance and defects, which makes trial-tested litigation experience especially valuable. Will Riley and Russell Cate lead our construction litigation team. Russell Cate is recognized as a Super Lawyer and has argued alongside Will Riley before the Indiana Court of Appeals and the Indiana Supreme Court, giving construction clients access to real appellate depth alongside trial experience. Will Riley’s Super Lawyers, Top 100 Trial Lawyers, and AV Preeminent recognition reflects the same trial credibility we bring to every construction matter.

Every matter we take on is personally overseen by Will and Russell, who staff it with the attorneys, associates, and staff it calls for based on its size and complexity, so you get consistent, informed attention whether your matter is a straightforward lien filing or a complex multi-party dispute. We also offer alternatives to the standard billable hour for qualifying matters, which can make sense for the extended timelines construction disputes sometimes involve. Because we take the time to understand your business before a dispute ever happens, we’re able to move faster and with better context once one does, rather than starting from scratch trying to understand your contracts and relationships in the middle of a crisis.

Why Choose Us

Nobody plans to need a lawyer. When something goes wrong, what you need first is someone who will listen, tell you honestly where you stand, and take the next steps off your plate. That is how every case at RileyCate, LLC begins.

We represent individuals, families, and small businesses across Fishers, Indianapolis, and surrounding counties in personal injury and complex litigation, business and real estate disputes, criminal defense, and appeals.

Will Riley and Russell Cate personally oversee every matter, staffing each case to its size and complexity. Both are recognized as Super Lawyers and have argued before the Indiana Court of Appeals and Supreme Court. Will also holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell and a Top 100 Trial Lawyer designation.

We are trial-tested, not just settlement-focused. We have tried hundreds of cases, because insurance companies, opposing businesses, and prosecutors negotiate differently with a firm willing to go the distance.

About RileyCate

Construction litigation covers disputes that arise out of building projects, including payment disputes, mechanic’s liens, construction defects, delay claims, and disagreements over the terms of a construction contract. It can involve owners, general contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, architects, and sureties, sometimes all in the same case. The right approach depends on which parties are involved and what the underlying contracts say, and a single project dispute can easily touch several of these categories at once.
A mechanic’s lien is a legal claim against a property that secures payment for labor or materials furnished to improve it, available to contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers who haven’t been paid. Indiana law sets specific deadlines for recording a lien and for filing suit to foreclose on it, so timing matters a great deal. Missing these deadlines can mean losing the right to use this remedy entirely.
Liability for a construction defect depends on what caused it and who was responsible for that part of the work, which could be the general contractor, a subcontractor, the architect or engineer, or in some cases a materials manufacturer. Determining liability often requires expert analysis of the defect itself. Indiana also applies a statute of repose that limits how long after substantial completion a defect claim can be brought.
Start by reviewing your contract for payment terms and any notice requirements, then act quickly, since Indiana’s mechanic’s lien deadlines run from the date you last provided labor or materials. Depending on the situation, you may have options including a lien claim, a bond claim on a public project, or a straightforward breach of contract claim. An attorney can help you identify the fastest and most effective path to payment.
Delays can give rise to a claim when they’re caused by another party’s failure to perform, such as an owner failing to provide access to the site or a contractor falling behind schedule without justification, and the delay causes measurable financial harm. Whether a delay is excusable or compensable often depends on what the contract says and who caused it. Good documentation throughout a project is one of the most important factors in proving a delay claim later.
We represent owners, general contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers, depending on who needs representation in a given dispute. Construction litigation often involves more than two parties, and our approach to building a case is the same regardless of where our client sits in the contract chain. What matters most is a clear understanding of the contracts and facts involved, not which link in the chain our client happens to occupy.
Ideally, before you sign a contract, since a review at that stage can help you avoid provisions that create problems later, including unfavorable indemnification clauses or unclear change order procedures. If a dispute has already started, earlier involvement still gives you more options than waiting until positions have hardened. We work with contractors, developers, and property owners at both stages, not just after a dispute has already escalated, because the relationships we build before a problem happens tend to produce faster, less costly resolutions when one eventually does.
Performance and payment bonds are typically required on public construction projects and guarantee that a contractor will complete the work and pay subcontractors and suppliers. If a contractor defaults, a claim against the bond can provide a path to recovery separate from a mechanic’s lien, which generally isn’t available on public property. Bond claims have their own notice and filing deadlines that are important to meet.
Many construction disputes are resolved through negotiation, mediation, or arbitration, especially when the underlying contract requires it or when preserving a business relationship matters to both sides. Being genuinely prepared to litigate if those methods fail tends to produce better results at the table, since the other side knows you’re not bluffing. We evaluate each situation to determine whether a faster resolution path makes sense or whether litigation is the better route.
Construction litigation takes place in court before a judge, while arbitration is a private process, often required by the construction contract itself, where a neutral arbitrator decides the outcome. Arbitration can be faster and more specialized, since arbitrators sometimes have construction industry experience, but it also generally limits your ability to appeal an unfavorable decision. Whether arbitration applies to your dispute depends entirely on what your specific contract requires.

Whether you’re dealing with a payment problem, a defect claim, or you simply want a construction litigation attorney in your corner before a dispute happens, we’re glad to talk. We offer a consultation to review your contracts, your project history, and your situation. Reach out to RileyCate today to speak with a construction litigation attorney about your project.

What Our Clients Say

Related News

Slip and Fall Sign

Indianapolis Slip & Fall Lawyer – When You Need One, and What to Expect

Truck Accident Lawyer Indianapolis: Recovering Big in Semi-Collision Cases

Best Indianapolis Car Accident Lawyer: How to Choose & Contact One